Avondale Elementary School vs. Barrett Elementary School

Avondale Elementary School, a Birmingham, AL public school serving grades PK–5, ranked #971 in Alabama in 2023, showing moderate improvement from #1098 in 2021 but remaining in the bottom 50% statewide.

Math proficiency ranged between 10–14%, reading proficiency between 25–29%, and science proficiency between 11–19%, all lower than the Alabama state averages in the latest reporting years.

Enrollment declined from 573 students in 2019 to 327 in 2023, while minority enrollment remained high at 84%, with Black students comprising the majority; around 73% of students qualified for free lunch, indicating persistent socioeconomic challenges.

The school maintained a student–teacher ratio of 16:1 in 2023, securing a top 20% ranking in student attention among Alabama public schools, with a teaching staff of 20 serving 327 students.

Barrett Elementary School ranked #1,146 in Alabama in 2023, showing a decline from #642 in 2012 and remaining in the bottom 50% of state public schools.

Math proficiency in 2023 was 5%, significantly lower than the state average of 30%, while reading proficiency ranged between 20–24%, also lower than the state average of 47%, and science proficiency was 5%, below the state average of 38%.

Enrollment was 415 students in grades PK–5 in 2023, with a student–teacher ratio of 21:1, and the school had a high rate of socioeconomic need, with 86% of students eligible for free lunch.

The student body was predominantly Black (336 of 415 students), with Hispanic students numbering 70, indicating stable minority enrollment in this Birmingham, Alabama elementary school.

Barrett Elementary provided no virtual instruction and operated under the Birmingham City education agency with Title I eligibility, reflecting consistent policies to support low–income families.