For the 2025-26 school year, there are 10 public elementary schools serving 6,914 students in Bay Shore, NY.
The top ranked public elementary schools in Bay Shore, NY are Bay Shore Middle School, Gardiner Manor School and South Country School. Overall testing rank is based on a school's combined math and reading proficiency test score ranking.
Bay Shore, NY public elementary schools have an average math proficiency score of 41% (versus the New York public elementary school average of 52%), and reading proficiency score of 32% (versus the 48% statewide average). Elementary schools in Bay Shore have an average ranking of 2/10, which is in the bottom 50% of New York public elementary schools.
Minority enrollment is 85% of the student body (majority Hispanic), which is more than the New York public elementary school average of 61% (majority Hispanic).
Best Public Elementary Schools in Bay Shore, NY (2025-26)
School
(Math and Reading Proficiency)
(Math and Reading Proficiency)
Location
Quick Facts
Rank: #11.
Bay Shore Middle School
(Math: 51% | Reading: 43%)
Rank:
Rank:
5/
Bottom 50%10
393 Brook Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 968-1208
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 968-1208
Gr: 6-8 | 1,269 student Student-teacher ratio: 11:1 Minority enrollment: 77%
Rank: #22.
Gardiner Manor School
(Math: 44% | Reading: 34%)
Rank:
Rank:
4/
Bottom 50%10
125 Wohseepee Dr
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 968-1150
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 968-1150
Gr: 3-5 | 714 students Student-teacher ratio: 12:1 Minority enrollment: 77%
Rank: #33.
South Country School
(Math: 40-44% | Reading: 34%)
Rank:
Rank:
3/
Bottom 50%10
885 Hampshire Rd
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 968-1250
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 968-1250
Gr: 3-5 | 489 students Student-teacher ratio: 9:1 Minority enrollment: 70%
Rank: #44.
Hemlock Elementary School
(Math: 37% | Reading: 30-34%)
Rank:
Rank:
3/
Bottom 50%10
19 Hemlock Dr
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 434-2451
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 434-2451
Gr: K-5 | 638 students Student-teacher ratio: 13:1 Minority enrollment: 95%
Rank: #55.
Oak Park Elementary School
(Math: 32% | Reading: 30-34%)
Rank:
Rank:
2/
Bottom 50%10
775 Wisconsin Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 434-2255
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 434-2255
Gr: K-5 | 716 students Student-teacher ratio: 13:1 Minority enrollment: 98%
Rank: #66.
West Middle School
(Math: 41% | Reading: 26%)
Rank:
Rank:
2/
Bottom 50%10
2030 Udall Rd
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 434-2371
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 434-2371
Gr: 6-8 | 894 students Student-teacher ratio: 11:1 Minority enrollment: 96%
Rank: #77.
Southwest Elementary School
(Math: 31% | Reading: 18%)
Rank:
Rank:
1/
Bottom 50%10
1095 Joselsen Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 434-2261
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 434-2261
Gr: K-5 | 955 students Student-teacher ratio: 13:1 Minority enrollment: 94%
Rank: n/an/a
45 Brook Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 968-1130
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 968-1130
Gr: K-2 | 388 students Student-teacher ratio: 8:1 Minority enrollment: 78%
Rank: n/an/a
217 5th Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 968-1140
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 968-1140
Gr: K-2 | 359 students Student-teacher ratio: 9:1 Minority enrollment: 63%
Rank: n/an/a
1415 E 3rd Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 968-1204
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 968-1204
Gr: K-2 | 492 students Student-teacher ratio: 9:1 Minority enrollment: 80%
Bay Shore, New York Public Schools (Closed)
School
Location
Quick Facts
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top ranked public elementary schools in Bay Shore, NY?
The top ranked public elementary schools in Bay Shore, NY include Bay Shore Middle School, Gardiner Manor School and South Country School.
How many public elementary schools are located in Bay Shore?
10 public elementary schools are located in Bay Shore.
What is the racial composition of students in Bay Shore?
Bay Shore public elementary schools minority enrollment is 85% of the student body (majority Hispanic), which is more than the New York public elementary schools average of 61% (majority Hispanic).
Which public elementary schools in Bay Shore are often viewed compared to one another?
Popular comparisons of public elementary schools in Bay Shore include: Fifth Avenue School vs. Mary G Clarkson School, Mary G Clarkson School vs. Fifth Avenue School, Fifth Avenue School vs. Brook Avenue Elementary School
Recent Articles
School Choice vs. Neighborhood Schools: Key Factors
Explore school choice vs. neighborhood schools in 2025. Learn key factors parents should weigh when deciding the best fit for their child.
Best School Match 2025: Public vs Charter vs Magnet
Compare 2025 public, charter, and magnet school options with updated data, trends, and strategies to find the best fit.
Public School Boundaries and Equity in 2025
Explore how public school boundaries shape access, equity, and opportunity for students in 2025. Learn the impact on families and education policy.
