Should Schools Conduct Background Checks on Teachers?
With the growing scandals surrounding teachers, more parents and community leaders are calling for greater background checks. Learn about both sides of the debate in keeping all students safe.
Once considered society’s role models, today’s teachers have been caught in a media frenzy of scandalous and questionable behavior. In turn, parents and community members are voicing their justified concerns regarding how public schools are evaluating their employees.
While the national statistics regarding teachers and their potential criminal connections are still vague, many cities and school districts have begun implementing their own investigations of public school workers. For example, as WTAE Pittsburgh News reports, recent 2007 investigations uncovered a list of criminal convictions in various teachers’ files, including charges of stalking, theft, and assault, among other crimes. Subsequently, more leaders are debating how to more effectively evaluate each public school employee’s credentials, integrity, and background.
Are Schools Engaging in Effective Background Checks?
While all public schools are required to conduct background checks on its newly hired teachers, most public schools do not continue to randomly check a teacher’s criminal file once they are added to the school’s payroll system. As a result, some teachers may enter into their career without any record, yet may commit unnoticed crimes while working for the school.
Adding to this concern, as WTAE News further reveals, many teacher candidates can pass a basic background check – even if their record posts convictions of crimes such as assault, theft, and fraud! Among the 135 teachers with criminal records in Pittsburgh Public Schools, investigators discovered that some of the more serious charges were incidents ranging from possession of heroin and crack, all the way to embezzlement charges totaling $7,000. One local teacher even had a current warrant for her arrest!
Adding to the local Pittsburgh discoveries, the WAOI San Antonio News team recently uncovered criminal histories surrounding several teachers. Among some of the offenders found in the schools, WAOI reported one teacher’s history of criminal public lewdness and another teacher’s record of indecent exposure.
How did these crimes go unnoticed by schools conducting background checks? Experts state that the holes in the background check system still allow individuals to pass an assessment when their records consist of simple assault, fraud, and/or theft.
How Should Public Schools React?
Based upon recent discoveries of teachers’ secret pasts, a debate is being raised over how schools can more effectively conduct criminal background investigations. In beginning a safer approach to reviewing employee credentials, all applicants to public schools must meet both state and federal background check standards. As the Iowa Department of Public Safety explains, applicants undergo a thorough national evaluation, as all teachers must now have digital fingerprints, an FBI evaluation, and a criminal records assessment of any crimes or violations committed in any of the 50 states. A background check is also conducted at a local level to investigate any further criminal issues.
While nearly all school and community members agree that teachers and school workers should undergo an extensive criminal background check, some argue that a public school employee’s records should be sealed from the public’s knowledge. For example, many websites are now devoted solely to reporting teachers’ crimes. While the public and students should certainly be informed of any danger surrounding a school employee, many citizens argue that publicizing all criminal blunders only serves to invade the public school workers’ privacy.
Some individuals believe that teachers and public workers should be able to manage their misdemeanor crimes, such as disorderly conduct, drug possession, or theft, with greater modesty and privacy. Adding to this, many individuals assert that misdemeanor classifications may often be misinterpreted; for example, if an employee is rowdy at an athletic event, the individual could potentially be cited with a misdemeanor for his or her conduct. As a result, many community members are seeking to negotiate an agreement between providing all parents and students with safe and highly qualified educators versus allowing all community members to invade the private lives of its public school employees.
In addition, many believe that schools need to monitor the criminal activities and records of existing staff to ensure that all faculty members are maintaining a proper code of conduct. Ultimately, while the majority of public school teachers possess no form of criminal history, the public continues to seek out greater protective measures to ensure that students stay safe.
November 09, 2017
The Common Core State Standards Initiative, more commonly referred to simply as “Common Core”, was introduced to help American students graduate from high school better prepared for career and college. But what exactly are these "common core" standards, and are they working?
November 07, 2017
In Indiana, a voucher program is up and running and changing the face of public education in the state.
October 25, 2017
Empower yourself and your children by learning what parents can do to protect their children from bullies and bullying behavior as they enter this new school year.