The Ongoing Debate Over School Choice
School choice is one of the most controversial topics in education today, but what are the benefits and disadvantages it really brings to children? Learn more about school choice and what it truly means to your children.
There are few topics as fiercely debated in the world of education today as school choice and voucher programs. The subject becomes particularly prevalent in areas where public schools are not making the grade, but has also been seen in districts where the public schools are performing well. However, parents want more opportunities and choices for their children. No matter what side of the fence a parent or educator might be on, chances are the emotions surrounding this topic run high. We’ll take a closer look at the school choice idea, including the history of the programs and the pros and cons that make this issue one of the hot-button subjects around the country.
Which School to Choose?
One reason school choice has become a major point of contention is due to the fact that there are many options in education today. Districts offer a wide range of school types, and parents are faced with choices that they may not have had just a few decades earlier. Some of the schools seen in communities today include:
Neighborhood Public Schools
Public schools are funded by the government, so they must follow certain guidelines set forth by state regulators. These schools are free to all children to attend, and the proximity to homes in the neighborhood makes them easy for children to attend. Schools are typically assigned by district zoning regulations, although some districts allow students to attend another public school outside their immediate neighborhood if there is sufficient space in the school for that student.
Charter schools are also public schools, so no tuition is required to attend. However, these schools are not set up by the state; instead, they are established independently through teachers, parents and community members. The schools are not subject to the same state and federal requirements that govern other public schools, but they are held to a high accountability level in terms of their performance. Parents must request that their children are enrolled in the school, and high parental involvement is strongly encouraged at most charters.
Magnet schools are also public schools without tuition requirements. These schools typically have a particular focus, such as science or the arts. In some cases, students may have to take a test to qualify for enrollment in the schools; others allow for enrollment according to parental request alone.
Virtual schools, also referred to as distance learning, are schools that are conducted via the Internet. Students usually take classes from the comfort of home and at their own pace. Virtual schools are subject to strict government and district guidelines to ensure students who choose this mode of instruction receive the same quality of education as those in the classroom.
Private schools can be religious or secular in nature. These schools charge tuition to attend, and are designed to support parental beliefs in how children should be educated, whether religious, academic or otherwise. These schools are often the subject of the voucher debate, since vouchers can be used to help pay the tuition at private schools.
With a home school, parents become the teachers and provide students with personalized instruction customized to their own pace and learning style. Parents are subject to state rules to ensure students get a similar quality of education to what they would receive in the classroom.
With many choices in education today, parents can select the style of schooling that is the best fit for their children. The school voucher program takes this a step further, by offering parents additional funding to help them pay for the school of their choice.
The Idea Behind School Vouchers
School voucher programs work on the idea that parents should be able to choose the best school for their children, rather than the state or local school district. These programs take the tax dollars that would normally pay for the public education system and give them directly to parents to pay for their children’s education as they see fit. Parents can take the funding and use it for private school tuition if they prefer. The amount of funding parents receive is based on what the schools typically get for each student, each school year. While the amount may not be sufficient for covering the full tuition cost of a private school for a year, the argument is that if parents do not have to pay into the public school system, they will be more likely to afford the type of education that they deem is best for their children.
School vouchers have a long history in this country, even though the debate over such programs as accelerated in recent years. According to a publication by the Economic Policy Institute, the idea of using public funding for private schooling dates all the way back to the 1960s, when liberal academics began to argue that the racial inequalities in the current school system could not be adequately addressed through a residentially segregated public school system. These advocates of a fair and equal education system were clamoring for a voucher system even during this time, as a means of breaking the “monopoly” that public education had become. Although the debate at the time eventually fizzled out without seeing any real change to public school policy, the inequalities brought forth in these arguments continue to be a source of concern today.
The Pros of School Vouchers
There are many arguments made in favor of school vouchers today. Some of these assertions include:
- School vouchers empower parents to make choices for their children, based on their children’s unique needs, interests and learning styles.
- School vouchers eliminate the need for parents to pay twice for their children’s education: once in tax dollars and again in tuition costs.
- School vouchers meet children’s needs more effectively by allowing them to go to the school that is the best fit for them, rather than the one that is simply in the neighborhood.
- The government-run education system currently isn’t working; schools are failing and students are falling through the cracks.
- A voucher system promotes competition between area schools, which raises the bar on the standard of education throughout all schools, including public schools.
- Vouchers offer students in low-income areas with poorly performing schools a chance at a better education and the opportunity to break the cycle of poverty.
Those in favor of school vouchers may advocate for the system to come alongside the current public school system – or replace it entirely. Those on the far side of the school voucher debate believe that the government is simply incapable of managing the school system and support complete privatization of schools across the country.
The Cons of School Vouchers
While the potential benefits of school vouchers are great, there are many drawbacks to the system as well. Those who oppose a school voucher system often present the following arguments against vouchers:
- School vouchers take money away from the public school system – and budgets currently are so tight in many school districts across the country, additional cuts could seriously undermine the value of public education today.
- Because many private schools are religious, the allowance of using tax dollars to pay for private schools that subscribe to a particular faith is a blatant violation of the constitutional separation of church and state.
- Vouchers do not benefit all students, since private schools still have the ability to pick and choose which students attend and could discriminate against certain students if they so choose.
- With more schools vying for tuition money, the quality of private schooling may suffer in the process, leaving some parents actually paying out of pocket for a lesser education than they would get from public schools.
- School vouchers skim the best students away from the public school system, making it that much more difficult for public schools to make the grade on standardized test scores and get subsequent funding for higher scores.
- A school voucher system tends to divide the country, while public education serves to unite it.
While both the pros and cons of school vouchers reach those heading to the voting booths to determine the future of schools in their area, not all of these arguments are weighted in cold hard facts. Next, we’ll dispel some of the common myths that circulate about school choice and voucher programs.
Dispelling the Myths of School Choice
Some of the arguments made in favor of or opposing school choice and vouchers simply don’t hold much water when the facts are presented. It is important to get the right information before determining whether a voucher program is the best choice for a specific community. According to a report in Time, some of the common myths of school voucher programs include:
Vouchers take the best students away from public schools.
Because many of the voucher programs introduced today are designed specifically for students from low-income families or special needs students, this myth does not appear to be based in fact. According to an op-ed piece in the Washington Post, research done on students transferring to charter schools showed that the students who made the move had similar or lower achievement levels to their peers prior to transferring.
Vouchers improve performance in some school districts.
While this statement seems like common sense – after all, competition typically increases quality in a free enterprise system – this theory doesn’t appear to transfer well to the public school system. The Times reports that voucher systems that have been in operation for some time in Milwaukee and Cleveland have not had any impact on the quality of public schools in those cities.
Vouchers take money away from the public school system.
While this statement might be true in some districts, it is not a given for every voucher program that is implemented. For example, an analysis of the voucher program in Milwaukee showed that vouchers actually save money on public education from year to year. A voucher program in Washington D.C. resulted in an infusion of federal money into the public school system, eliminating concern over the impact of vouchers on school budgets.
Private schools always offer a better quality of education than public schools.
While some of the private schools, and even charter schools, may impress with their test scores and graduation rates, that doesn’t mean the private school down the street is a better fit for a specific child than the neighborhood public school. Parents need to weigh the pros and cons of each available school before making the best choice for their children.
Parents make better school choices for their children.
Finding the best fit in a school can take plenty of time and research – and not all parents are able to invest the effort to find the best school situation, and some simply don’t have the knowledge or background to even know what criteria to evaluate when choosing a school. According to the Washington Post article, parents who chose a charter school for their children did not always choose schools that performed better than the public schools in their neighborhood.
Voucher Programs – Do They Work?
With so much information flying around about school choice and voucher programs – and relatively few programs to look at to see if the system really does offer benefits – it can be difficult to know whether this approach to education really will raise the bar on academic performance across the country. Three voucher systems are currently going strong in Milwaukee, Cleveland and Washington D.C. There have been some bright spots in these areas. Washington D.C. has managed to raise graduation rates through their school choice program, and data from Milwaukee shows a higher level of parental satisfaction with their children’s schools since the voucher program went into effect. In Cleveland, various studies performed on the benefits of vouchers provided conflicting results, so it is difficult to assess the true outcome of this ongoing program at this time.
With school choice continuing to be a hot topic for parents and educators across the country, this subject is still one of the most debated in education circles across the country. It may be some time before enough voucher systems are put in place to provide sufficient data for a final determination on whether these programs can actually benefit the students they serve.
July 12, 2018
Being a teacher has never been easy but changes in federal funding and legislation have made it harder than ever for public school teachers. Keep reading to learn more.
July 12, 2018
Meal delivery services are all the rage these days, but could they be the solution to the school lunch problem? Keep reading to find out!
May 18, 2018
Find out where the members of the 115th House of Representatives went to school and how many chose private school over public school for their own children.