Public School Holiday Celebrations: Christmas-centric or Multicultural?

Public School Holiday Celebrations:  Christmas-centric or Multicultural?
As public schools in the United States continue to increase in their racial, ethnic, economic, and religious diversity, some districts need to rethink their holiday celebrations in a manner that is inclusive and respectful of all people.
With the children home for the holidays, with the spirit of love and peace in their hearts, how did their schools celebrate the season?  Or did they celebrate Christmas? 
In many locations, holiday parties involve decorating contests that include Christmas trees and ornaments. In elementary schools, Santa might make an appearance.  Songs of reindeer and gifts ring out, along with talk of who’s been naughty or nice. Children are asked to write essays on “what I want for Christmas,” or after the holidays, they are asked to explain what gifts they received.
However, this Christmas-centric view does not align well with the actual makeup of today’s public schools. Research shows that today’s public schools are more diverse than ever. While the data tends to speak from an ethnic or racial point of view, it is still indicative of the need to take multiple perspectives into account.  Schools have to begin to recognize that not all children celebrate Christmas and have made adjustments that make their celebrations more inclusive. However, there is still much work to be done if public schools are to have a truly multicultural perspective. 
In this video, The Doctors discuss a recent news story about a school district that banned all dominant holiday celebrations in the name of inclusion.
Unintended Consequences
There remain many public schools in this country that engage in holiday celebrations that revolve around Christian ideas and principles as they pertain to Christmas. While these celebrations are no doubt intended to spread Christmas joy, there are negative consequences to these kinds of celebrations for children who do not belong to the Christian faith or who do not celebrate Christmas at all.
Children who practice Islam, Hinduism, and Buddhism do not celebrate Christmas. Many Jewish families do not hang stockings or exchange gifts on Christmas day. Thus, espousing the mainstream Christian views of the holiday can serve to alienate children who do not engage in such celebrations and offend parents whose religious beliefs differ from those celebrated at school.
In an effort to add diversity to holiday celebrations, some teachers believe that recognizing the Jewish holiday Chanukah or mentioning Kwanzaa, both of which also occur in December, is enough to make holiday parties and curricular activities multicultural. However, critics argue that doing so serves to amplify the problem, rather than fix it.
First, Chanukah does not hold the same importance for Jews as Christmas does for Christians. Instead, Passover, which occurs in the spring, and Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, which occur in the fall, are much more important. Second, because the majority of public school teachers are white, it can be assumed that the vast majority knows little or nothing about Kwanzaa in practice, which was created in 1966 as a ritual for African Americans to welcome the first harvest home. Offering celebrations at school in line with that holiday could seem trivial to students who celebrate it.
Some teachers may reach out to children who practice one of these religions or have alternative cultural beliefs in order to get a better understanding of their beliefs. The unintended consequence of doing so is that these children may feel singled out. Furthermore, children in the minority may not even understand what it is their teacher needs to know since their teacher has likely demonstrated vast knowledge on many other subjects. It may cause the child to wonder why their teacher never took the time to learn about something that is so important in their life.
This puts teachers in a very tough position because without a more multicultural point of view, children of the majority are led down a path of ethnocentrism, albeit unintentionally. By seeing their majority beliefs imposed upon classmates who do not celebrate Christmas, children may get the impression that their worldview and traditions are the only ones or at least the most important one.
This isn’t to say that teachers or public school systems intend to belittle students for their religious beliefs or cultural practices. On the contrary, most public school teachers genuinely wish to be sensitive to each child’s individual needs. However, the status quo of celebrating Christmas, and even referring to the winter break as “Christmas Break” in public schools, remains the primary culprit of this problem. But having a discussion that casts such good-intended events in a negative manner can be difficult to undertake.
How to Celebrate in a Multicultural Manner
If you celebrate Christmas in your family, you can assume – rightfully – that most of your child’s classmates also celebrate Christmas. However, not all children share the same beliefs. If you come from a religious or cultural view that does not celebrate Christmas, you likely have a heightened awareness of the holiday celebration problem that is present in many public schools.
However, there are a number of steps that can help these parties celebrate less about a specific religion or social practice and more about the beliefs that are common to many religions and cultural practices – goodwill towards others, charity, and family – among them.  Celebrate the season of giving, from human being to being.
Regardless of how your child's school celebrated the holidays, there are many ways parents can enrich understanding at home.  What a meaningful addition to a child's winter break! 
  • Emphasize the spirit of giving – Children can study historical figures that spent their lives focused on the needs of others. Children can also make gifts for one another, their parents, or other family members. Taking part in a food drive or toy drive for less fortunate families is another great way to teach about the spirit of giving.
  • Hold multicultural celebrations – Recognizing the diverse beliefs of children in a given classroom should extend beyond the month of December. To give credence to various beliefs, celebrations could occur throughout the year at the appropriate time. Celebrations could include a history lesson on the development of the holiday or an investigation of the cultural significance of the celebration.
  • Limit celebrations to foundational ideas – An essential part of multiculturalism is to inform children about various points of view, but doing so without getting into the religious aspects of celebrations can be difficult to do. However, by focusing on foundational ideas such as charity, celebrations become more universal without the added layer of religious debate.
  • Maintain anti-bias goals – Holiday celebrations can be used as a vehicle for an examination of the similarities and differences that make us so great. Exposing these differences, and celebrating them in a non-judgmental manner, is an excellent lesson for children to learn.

This video offers suggestions on how educators can celebrate Religious holidays within a public school classroom

What You Can Do as a Parent
How did your child's school fare this year in celebrating the holidays?  Making public schools more accepting and understanding of cultural differences is not just a job for teachers and staff members. As a parent, you have ample opportunities to help your child and his or her classmates adopt a multicultural worldview -- around the year. 
  • Educate your child –  Regardless of your religious or cultural traditions, be sure your child understands what they are and why you celebrate them. If you choose not to celebrate holidays, help your child understand why. Having this knowledge will allow them to share their perspective with others and develop an environment of understanding and respect.
  • Educate your child’s teacher – Give your child’ teacher background on your family’s belief system. This doesn’t need to be an in-depth discussion of Kwanzaa, Judaism, or whatever your belief system might be. But giving your child’s teacher a background at the beginning of the year will allow them to make considerations when it comes to holiday celebrations, class discussions, and lesson planning. If teachers aren’t aware of your child’s worldview, they can’t possibly make it a part of a multicultural classroom environment.
  • Offer to help – Particularly if you practice a belief system that is among the minority, offering your assistance to your child’s teacher can be invaluable. Help plan a classroom celebration, offer to speak to the class about your beliefs or lead a discussion about multiculturalism. Your insights will prove valuable to the children, and their teacher will appreciate the assistance.

This video illustrates one way to teach children the importance of giving.

Make Multiculturalism a Year-Round Venture
Multiculturalism is not something that should only make an appearance in December. Rather, teaching and learning should include lessons that open children up to other cultures and viewpoints year-round. But this means that teachers have to work hard to ensure that each child experiences cultural relevancy each and every day. Classroom decorations, lessons, activities, and the like should look, feel, and sound familiar to what children experience at home. Children should feel comfortable expressing who they are and sharing their experience with their classmates. When this is done, children feel a deeper sense of connection to one another and also feel as though their unique perspectives are respected and validated.
Questions? Contact us on Facebook. @publicschoolreview
Additional Resources [+]
comments powered by Disqus

Recent Articles

Prevent Suicide
Prevent Suicide
988 is the suicide and crisis lifeline. Parents, teachers, and students can help prevent suicide once they know the warning signs.
Georgia Schools: Atlanta Schools Cheating Scandal
Georgia Schools: Atlanta Schools Cheating Scandal
We report on the indictments of 35 Atlanta educators that were found guilty of their participation in the largest public school cheating scandal in U.S. history.
Alabama Schools: New Active Shooter Policies
Alabama Schools: New Active Shooter Policies
Alabama schools, including those in the large district of Mobile County, will institute new “active shooter” policies in partnership with the Alabama Department of Homeland Security.

Public School Policies

A Relevant History of Public Education in the United States
A Relevant History of Public Education in the United States
What is Race to the Top and How will it Benefit Public Schools?
What is Race to the Top and How will it Benefit Public Schools?
The Ongoing Debate Over School Choice
The Ongoing Debate Over School Choice
More Articles
Read more articles (94)