Understanding the Consequences of Banning Books in K-12 Education

Understanding the Consequences of Banning Books in K-12 Education

Our children were born in the early 70s. There was no Internet. Indeed, there were no smartphones, computers, or tablets.

• Instead, our kids had a mother who read to them when they were a few weeks old.
• She also taught them how to read. We had books everywhere.

As a result, our children became voracious readers. They read fiction and non-fiction.

• It's no wonder both daughters earned degrees in American Language and Literature.
• That's why we must take the current controversy over book banning seriously.

The freedom to read is a fundamental right that forms the cornerstone of a robust democratic society.

• However, banning books in public K-12 schools has periodically surfaced throughout history, bringing this freedom under scrutiny.
• The American Library Association (ALA) records numerous instances of censorship challenges, highlighting the pervasive nature of this issue.

This video from PBS News reports on the top 10 books people have tried to ban.

Historical Examples

The negative impact of banning books in education becomes apparent when examining historical cases.

• A notable example includes Ray Bradbury's dystopian novel "Fahrenheit 451."
• Ironically, it is a commentary on the dangers of censorship itself, which frequently landed on the ALA's list of challenged books due to its "offensive language" and "unsuited to age group" complaints.
• Similarly, Harper Lee's "To Kill a Mockingbird," lauded for its penetrating exploration of racial inequality, has been frequently challenged or removed due to its use of racial slurs, racial themes, and alleged offensive content.
• Yet, denying students access to such literature risks whitewashing historical realities, making it more difficult to comprehend and engage with these profound societal issues.

In many cases, the banned books are the ones that tackle crucial, albeit uncomfortable, topics – race, gender, sexuality, religion, and politics.

• Not exposing children to these themes could lead to a lack of empathy, critical thinking skills, and awareness of societal problems.
• Shielding children from these crucial themes through practices such as book banning has far-reaching implications beyond limiting their literary exposure.
• It can cause a detrimental deficit in their ability to empathize with experiences outside their immediate understanding.
• It can also inhibit the development of their critical thinking skills and impair their awareness and knowledge of intricate societal problems that require their engagement and responsiveness for societal progress and reform.

This video from Insider News reports on the ten most challenging book titles.

The Case for Parental Guidance

According to the National Coalition Against Censorship (NCAC), banning books limits the range of ideas available to students, undermining the quality of their education.

• The NCAC suggests a more productive approach, i.e., parental guidance in reading.
• Parental guidance facilitates open dialogues around the complex ideas and themes presented in books.
• Instead of shielding children from uncomfortable topics, parents can guide their understanding and help them form their own informed opinions.
• This approach can aid in developing critical thinking skills, an essential part of a comprehensive education.

The American Psychological Association (APA) asserts that constructive conversations about complex topics can help children develop empathy.

• It also increases their understanding of social issues and enhances their decision-making abilities.
• By having these conversations, children are also provided a safe and nurturing environment to discuss their questions, thoughts, and concerns.

Grade Level Appropriate Guidance for Parents

Elementary School

1. Start with Open Dialogue: Explain to your child why some books may be controversial, ensuring to keep the language age-appropriate. Frame it in a way that encourages curiosity and inquiry.
2. Read Together: If a book is banned or challenged in your child's school, consider reading it with them at home. This allows you to directly guide their understanding and discuss any difficult topics as they arise.

Middle School

1. Promote Critical Thinking: Children start forming more complex ideas and views at this stage. Encourage them to question what they read, fostering a critical perspective. If a book is banned, discuss the reasons and whether they agree or disagree, reinforcing that their opinion matters.
2. Supplement School Learning: If a book has been removed from the curriculum, consider integrating it into your child's home reading list. This broadens their reading scope and instigates meaningful conversations about censorship and freedom of speech.

High School

1. Understanding Context: Encourage your teen to research the reasons behind the banning of a book. It's an excellent opportunity to dig deeper into societal issues and gain a broader understanding of differing perspectives.
2. Cultivating Empathy: Some books are banned because they explore sensitive or mature topics. Instead of shying away, use these books as a tool to discuss these issues with your teenager. It's a chance to cultivate empathy, understanding, and acceptance of diversity.

Throughout all these stages, it's essential to reassure your child that reading a wide range of books, even controversial ones, is part of a well-rounded education.

• Remember, your role isn't to shield them from complex topics but to provide a supportive and understanding environment where they can explore, question, and form their own views.
• It's all part of them growing into informed, empathetic adults who can navigate the complexities of our world with grace and understanding.

Conclusion

Banning books can have detrimental effects on students' educational experiences.

• History has shown that the practice can limit students' exposure to different perspectives, stifle critical thinking, and hinder their understanding of important societal issues.
• In contrast, parental guidance in reading can provide a more enriching and nuanced educational experience.
• It allows children to grapple with difficult topics in a safe environment and helps them develop into thoughtful, informed adults.

As such, efforts should be made to empower parents and educators to guide students through difficult content rather than banning it outright.

Questions? Contact us on Facebook or Instagram. @publicschoolreview

#FreedomToRead #ParentalGuidance #Education #BannedBooks #Literacy #CriticalThinking #EmpathyInEducation