Growth of Charter Schools in D.C. Faces Controversy
Charter schools are growing in DC, and we analyze the response to recent numbers that show the student population in D.C. charter schools has outpaced the numbers for traditional public schools throughout the district.
Washington D.C. has become a school district where charter schools enroll nearly as many students as neighborhood public schools. As the charter model becomes more and more prevalent in the District, school officials are forced to look at the future path of public schooling in D.C. While some believe the exponential growth of charter schools is good thing for education quality overall, others fear the expansion of these schools will permanently put traditional public schools in a minority position, where they will lack clout and resources to effectively educate D.C. children.
Charter School Growth: Numbers don’t Lie
Charter schools first came to Washington D.C. in 1996. The movement has slowly expanded across the school district, to the point where 43 percent of D.C.’s students attend one of these schools today. That translates to nearly 35,000 students at 100 campuses across the city, according to Education Week. Charter school enrollment appears to be on a path to continue this expansion by approximately 10 percent each year.
According to the Washington Post, enrollment in traditional public schools in the District was at just over 45,000 in 2012. The number indicated a one-percent growth in public school enrollment from 2011 to 2012. If that trend continues, it won’t be long before charter school enrollment outpaces enrollment at traditional public schools.
The competition with charter schools has taken its toll on D.C.’s public school system overall. This year, low enrollment numbers are forcing DCPS Chancellor Kaya Henderson to close another 15 schools in the district. Those closures do not come without a cost – the Washington Post reports that parents, teachers and activists have now called for district officials to formulate a plan that will allow charters and neighborhood schools to co-exist.
The Fight for Neighborhood Schools
A second report from the Washington Post states that community members are concerned about what the shift in the education model will mean to students, neighborhoods and taxpayers throughout the District. With a recent proposal by a California non-profit group to open eight more charter schools enrolling 5,000 more students by 2019, the stakes are even higher. The proposal has come on the heels of the closure of 15 schools, which makes the contrast between charters and neighborhood schools even more stark.
The problem is that because Washington D.C. is the first district to grapple with such charter school growth, the district doesn’t have much in the way of past history to fall back on. As it navigates unchartered territory in the wilderness of public education, other districts across the country will be watching carefully to see how the charter school influence shakes out in terms of academic performance and other factors.
“Certainly there are strengths to such an approach,” Washington D.C. Mayor Vincent C. Gray told the Washington Post. “But there are also challenges – challenges with which no city has yet grappled.”
While Gray appreciates that the current growth in charter schools has forced both sectors to improve their quality of education, as the balance begins to shift, concern increases as well. Gray explained to the Washington Post that “anything that tips the balance too far in one direction or the other is not good for our children.”
One of the problems with the dual approach could be that the schools are currently operating in isolation, preventing any sort of cohesion within the school system. D.C. Council member David Catania told the Washington Post that lawmakers have a responsibility to manage the process to ensure all schools in the District are going in the same direction. Catania also said charter growth could be positively influenced by lawmakers, if procedures were in place to accelerate the closure of charters not performing to standards and withholding student funding from new charters to discourage as many from opening.
Finding a Facility
Another issue that is plaguing the D.C. school district is finding facilities for the growing charter schools already in operation in the city. The Washington Examiner reports that while some charters would like to move into empty school buildings, the availability of those buildings is not always clear. One charter school that is planning to move to a public school building is shelling out $23 million to renovate a school that has sat empty since its closure in 2008. Much of the cost will be used to add amenities like a gym and theatre, but a significant portion of the money will go to update a school that has fallen into disrepair by sitting empty for so many years.
Another D.C. charter school is facing similar problems after bidding on another school building that has been sitting empty since 2008. The school had holes in the walls and unusable bathrooms that will cost more than $8 million to repair and renovate. Charter school proponents have long complained that the school district takes far too long to release empty buildings for charter school use, which increases the costs of reopening the buildings after so much time has passed. However, Thomas Porter, a real estate director that helps charter schools find buildings, told the Examiner the process is improving.
As charter school growth continues throughout D.C., questions will still remain over exactly how charters and neighborhood schools with be able to cohabitate peacefully. As the debate continues in the District, other schools districts across the country will be watching with interest to determine whether there will be a legitimate place for both neighborhood and charter schools in the future.
Being a teacher has never been easy but changes in federal funding and legislation have made it harder than ever for public school teachers. Keep reading to learn more.
Say goodbye to mystery meat - and all other types of meat - at public school cafeterias that are embracing the Meatless Monday trend.
Growing cases of contaminated tap water at public schools around the country are raising more than eyebrows. Learn about whether or not public schools' tap water is safe to drink.