Waiting for Superman: The Heroes and the Villains of Education

Updated |
Waiting for Superman: The Heroes and the Villains of Education
The latest educational documentary paints a controversial picture of today's educational problems and the right solutions. Learn about both sides of the debate stirred by Waiting for Superman.
"Waiting for Superman" is the latest documentary to be released into theatres, depicting the current state of public education today, with recommendations from experts in the field on how to improve a failing school system. This film precedes recent comments by President Obama on the importance of strengthening the quality of education in this country if we are to remain competitive in a global market.

It also comes at a time when severe budget cuts, thanks to the recent economic slowdown, have strapped already cash-pinched schools even further, forcing them to cut additional programs and staff at a time when the public school system appears to be on the brink of disaster.

"Waiting for Superman" is the brainchild of David Guggenheim, the same documentary film maker who brought us "An Inconvenient Truth," the documentary that rocketed former Vice President Al Gore to Nobel Peace Prize status. Sheila Curran Bernard, associate director for documentary film studies at University of Albany/SUNY, told USA Today, "What gives some of these films their power is not just the content, but also the craft. Imagine how dull 'An Inconvenient Truth' might have been if it were not shaped well."

Telling a Story
The same can be said of "Waiting for Superman," a film that follows five families through the public school experience, according to a synopsis on the official movie website. It illustrates how the educational welfare of many families in struggling school districts is left to chance – the luck of the draw in a lottery system will send just a handful of students to the best public or charter schools in the area.
The film paints a vivid picture that is heart-wrenching and hopeful at the same time. It is no wonder this film garnered ample attention prior to its release last week, and it continues to do so as reviews roll in on both sides of the spectrum.
Sparking Controversy
While it is not unusual for a documentary to unleash a myriad of controversy, "Waiting for Superman" appears to be generating more than the standard share. On the one hand, big names like Bill Gates and Oprah Winfrey are singing the praises of the documentary, believing that a full overhaul of our educational system is absolutely necessary if children from all walks of life will receive the same opportunities.
On the other hand, opponents of the documentary worry that demonizing teachers and teacher unions will only serve to put the future of education into the hands of business leaders and politicians, rather than giving control to the people who understand how to teach kids best.
Those in Favor
Bill Gates is one of the most vocal proponents of "Waiting for Superman." According to a report at Third Age, although Gates and his children had the good fortune to attend private school, he has long been a vocal supporter of high quality public education in this country. The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation has supplied grants for a wealth of educational opportunities. When Gates saw "Waiting for Superman" last year, he immediately came onboard to help promote the film because he saw firsthand how a documentary like this could further the cause of public education.
"It became obvious that we had an incredible opportunity because he'd told the story so well," Gates told Third Age.
Those Opposed
Despite the strong proponents of this documentary, there are also many that believe "Waiting for Superman" takes the wrong approach in attempting to reform education in this country.
In an editorial in Huffington Post, Jeanine Molloff accuses the film of heralding educational solutions funded by big business, while ignoring very real problems schools face today, such as slashed budgets and overcrowded classes. Molloff also claims that the film picks and chooses what to highlight about the current state of the education system, avoiding topics like censored curriculums and the impact of growing poverty on children, while singing the praises of "innovative" solutions proposed by charter schools.
There is no doubt that documentaries like "Waiting for Superman" have the capacity to sway public opinion and may even play a part in promoting some of the change that is much needed in our public schools today.  When it comes to the future of our kids, the answer is clear – public education does indeed require reform. The question then becomes, does "Waiting for Superman" offer real solutions to our educational dilemma or simply spark more controversy over the best way to educate our kids?

Additional Resources [+]
comments powered by Disqus
Can Public Schools Legally Charge for Fees and Uniforms?
Can Public Schools Legally Charge for Fees and Uniforms?
Should Teacher Salaries be Public Information?
Should Teacher Salaries be Public Information?
Recent Articles
The Common Core State Standards Initiative has changed the course of education in the United States, particularly with its emphasis on standardized testing. But how does standardized testing affect teaching quality? Keep reading to find out.
When asked to rank the quality of their child's school a B average. And yet politicians would have you believe that the American public-school system is failing. How are America's public schools really doing, and how do we know?
The high school graduation rate is in a constant state of change and dropout rates affect more than the individual student. Read on to learn about factors influencing high school graduation rates and what schools can do to improve them.
Public School Policies