School Controversies

The most controversial issues impacting public school students today. From bullying to book bans, this is a comprehensive look at some of the most oft-debated issues. This section features articles on school segregation, religion, over-crowding, civil rights, and green technology.

View the most popular articles in School Controversies:

Utah on its Way to Banning Sex-Ed in Schools

Updated
|
Utah on its Way to Banning Sex-Ed in Schools
The new bill, which has already passed state lawmakers, would ban public schools from teaching about contraception or sexually transmitted diseases. If it is signed into law by the governor, it will be the most conservative law in the country regarding sex education in schools.

This article has been updated to reflect 2026 data and recent developments.

Utah may have boasted the most restrictive sex education laws in the country if a bill passed through the state legislature in 2012 had been signed into law. The proposed law would have restricted schools from teaching any type of sex ed in public schools outside of abstinence and would have prohibited discussion on contraception and sexually transmitted diseases. Despite the fact that this bill passed in both the state House and Senate, there was plenty of opposition to the bill from state lawmakers, educators, and even parents. Governor Gary Herbert ultimately vetoed the bill on March 16, 2012.

About the Bill

Referred to as HB363 and sponsored by Bill Wright (R-Holden), this bill would have defined sex education in the state of Utah as abstinence-only and would have banned schools from providing instruction on sexual intercourse, homosexuality, contraceptive methods, and sexually transmitted diseases. According to Deseret News, Wright sponsored the bill as a response to what he called “inappropriate material” presented in classrooms. Specifically, Wright was opposed to material produced by Planned Parenthood being distributed to students. Wright said he believed sex education was something that should take place in the home, rather than the school.

At the time, Utah schools were allowed to offer sex-education courses with some restrictions attached. Schools were allowed to provide instruction about sexual intercourse and contraception without advocating for it. Parents could choose not to have their

. . .read more

Detroit Preparing for Major Shake-Up in School System Next Year

Updated
|
Detroit Preparing for Major Shake-Up in School System Next Year
Explore Detroit Public Schools' historic restructuring plan, including school closures, charter conversions, and community concerns, with updated 2026 context and insights.

When Roy Roberts became the emergency manager of Detroit Public Schools (now Detroit Public Schools Community District, or DPSCD), he took on the nearly impossible challenge of turning around a system that wasn’t doing justice to the nearly 70,000 students currently enrolled in the district at the time. However, instead of shying away from the challenge, Roberts took the proverbial bull by the horns and embarked on a major shake-up that was slated to occur during the following school year. While some applauded Roberts’ efforts, others were concerned about what the changes would mean to students, teachers, and the neighborhoods that many of these schools called home.

School Closures Just the Beginning

From overcrowding in Detroit Public School classrooms to facing bankruptcy, the challenges abounded for this Michigan school district. According to the Huffington Post, Roberts planned to close nine public schools and convert four more into charters in an effort to repair a broken system. This move was predicted to save Detroit Public Schools $7.5 million in annual operating costs, money that Roberts hoped to put toward educating children rather than maintaining empty classrooms.

"Rather than continue to support buildings that are far underutilized…we will consolidate,” Roberts was reported saying at Huffington Post. “We have been using an outdated educational model that we must discard,” Roberts added.

The Detroit Free Press reported that by that fall, Detroit Public Schools would be downsized to around 50,000 students, down from the nearly 70,000 then enrolled in the school district

. . .read more

Bringing the Bible Back to School: A Revival?

Updated
|
Bringing the Bible Back to School: A Revival?
A number of states are looking into add courses of biblical study, so that students can learn more about this aspect of our country’s history. However, concern over separation of church and state is a concern for many involved.

While some public schools have made their classrooms decidedly politically correct, including banning Christmas carols on campus, other states seem to be headed in the opposite direction. A number of states around the country are introducing legislation to bring the Bible back to school – purportedly as a resource for teaching the history of the United States, rather than advocating a particular religion. Still, many believe that biblical studies of any kind in public schools are a flagrant First Amendment violation. Which side is right? It turns out the matter may be too complex for a single, easy answer.

The First Amendment

The First Amendment states, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…”

“Largely because of this prohibition against government regulation or endorsement of religion, diverse faiths have flourished and thrived in America since the founding of the republic,” states the Anti-Defamation League. “Indeed, James Madison, the father of the United States Constitution, once observed that, ‘the [religious] devotion of the people has been manifestly increased by the total separation of the church from the state.”

The words of the Constitution sound relatively straightforward, but they have been hotly debated for generations. Determining what constitutes the separation of church and state is not an easy task, particularly when First Amendment issues enter into the public school forum. Prayer, Bible study, and teachings on creationism and evolution have all become hot-button issues in school districts

. . .read more

Banned Books Create Outcry in Arizona and Detroit

Updated
|
Banned Books Create Outcry in Arizona and Detroit
Recent bans on Shakespeare’s “The Tempest,” and newer novels “Beloved” and “Waterland” are creating an outcry among students, teachers – and the ACLU.

Book banning is an age-old concept that is nearly always met with a public outcry. That is certainly the case in two areas of the country today, where schools that have banned specific books from the classroom have been met with plenty of resistance from parents and educators. The ACLU has even involved itself in one of the situations, with a goal of protecting the civil rights of teachers and students. Is book banning appropriate in certain situations? We’ll take a look at what those involved are saying about the recent proposals to ban some pieces of literature from the classroom.

Arizona Ethnic Study Ban Includes Works by Shakespeare

Two years ago, Arizona instituted a law banning ethnic studies, a move that made headlines and ruffled many feathers in the world of education. According to a report at the Wall Street Journal, one high school teacher recently discovered that the ban includes “The Tempest” by William Shakespeare. The teacher had requested to begin teaching from the work but was told he would not be able to do so.

The now-former Arizona teacher, Curtis Acosta, wrote in a statement printed at the Wall Street Journal, “I asked if I could start teaching Shakespeare’s ‘The Tempest,’ and was told no, due to the themes that are present and the likelihood of avoiding discussions of colonization, enslavement, and racism were remote.”

The new Arizona law prohibits any type of course or class that “promotes the overthrow of the

. . .read more

Corruption Charges Filed against Five in San Diego School District Probe

Updated
|
Corruption Charges Filed against Five in San Diego School District Probe
Corruption charges involve two school district trustees, one former trustee, one former superintendent and a building contractor. Those involved accepted thousands of dollars in lavish gifts in return for building contracts from the district.

Corruption charges have been filed against four San Diego public school officials and one contractor in the largest corruption investigation in the recent history of this beach city. The investigation was prompted by allegations of bribes taken by public school trustees and one superintendent, and it uncovered widespread corruption in what the San Diego district attorney referred to as a “pay for play” culture. Current charges may not be the only ones filed, since the DA has revealed the investigation is ongoing and additional charges are possible.

Defendants Associated with San Diego Public Schools

According to a report at the Los Angeles Times, charges have been filed against Arlie Ricasa, Pearl Quinones, Greg Sandoval, Jesus Gandara, and Henry Amigable. Ricasa and Quinones are both Union High School Trustees that serve on the school board. Gandara is the former superintendent of the San Diego School District, who was fired from his post last June after receiving a $400,000 payout from the school system. Sandoval is also a former school board member. Amigable is a construction contractor, who worked for Sweetwater and Southwestern College, as well as securing contracts from the San Diego Public School system.

According to a report at Fox News, school officials charged in the probe racked up hundreds of dollars in lavish gifts provided by Amigable between 2008 and last year. Gifts included restaurant tabs, as well as airline, concert, and theatre tickets. Tickets to the Lakers’ playoff games and the Rose

. . .read more

Recent Articles

Can Public Schools Charge for Required Graduation Courses?
Can Public Schools Charge for Required Graduation Courses?
Can a public school charge for a course your child needs to graduate? Learn how state rules, course alternatives, summer programs, and fee waivers affect the answer, plus what parents should request before paying, accepting a substitute, or challenging a charge that threatens graduation plans.
Save Your Child's Work Before a School Account Closes
Save Your Child's Work Before a School Account Closes
School accounts may close after graduation or a transfer, leaving important projects inaccessible. Learn what families should save, which deadlines to confirm, how to check exported files, and why shared links alone may not preserve your child's work for future applications, learning, or personal memories.
School Commute Time: When Distance Affects School Fit
School Commute Time: When Distance Affects School Fit
Is your child's school commute becoming too demanding? Learn how to weigh educational benefits against daily strain, recognize warning signs, explore practical adjustments, and decide when a closer school fits.