Bullied to Death: Should Public Schools be More Responsible for Mean Girls?

Published April 08, 2010 |
Bullied to Death: Should Public Schools be More Responsible for Mean Girls?
In the wake of the Phoebe Prince tragedy, many are questioning whether schools should be more responsible for bullying.
While campus violence and bullying have been heated topics in recent years, the wake of a young teen's suicide, allegedly prompted by aggressive bullies, is forcing community members to reexamine the responsibility of schools in the fight against bullies

Should Schools Pay the Price for Bullying?
 
In the most recent high school tragedy, 15 year old Phoebe Prince sadly ended her own life after nine teenagers allegedly harassed and bullied the young girl. According to Slate News, District Attorney Elizabeth Scheibel has filed charges against the nine alleged bullies, further asserting that Phoebe Prince endured three months of extreme bullying under the awareness of some school leaders. According to Scheibel, “The investigation has revealed that certain faculty, staff, and administrators of the high school also were alerted to the harassment of Phoebe Prince before her death.” 
 
In fact, supporting these claims are reports from Phoebe’s mother, as well as fellow students, who reported obvious struggles endured by the teen. For example, Phoebe’s mother was so concerned about her daughter’s depression at school that she contacted school officials on multiple occasions, asking about whether or not students were making threats and attacks against her daughter. Furthermore, some students reported seeing Phoebe crying in the hallway outside her classroom, as well as crying in the nurse's office on the day she took her life.  
 
However, many argue that school leaders could not have been fully aware of Ms. Prince's harassment, and furthermore, they are in no way responsible for the young girl’s unfortunate death. 
 
Ultimately, in the wake of this unsettling tragedy, citizens are arousing the debate over whether or not schools are responsible for the misconduct of their students.
 
Are Schools Truly Responsible for Student Conduct?
 
In further examining the Phoebe Prince case, some local parents have demanded that the school’s principal resign, while others believe that some school board and administration members should resign as well. While attorneys are sifting through the claims and accounts of witnesses, none of the current evidence proves any correlation between the high school leaders and Phoebe’s death; in other words, even though she was bullied at the school, the school may not legally be responsible. 
 
Those who argue that the school cannot be responsible for Phoebe’s tragedy believe that bullying occurs beyond the boundaries of school walls, especially given the prevalence of social networking today. With technologies such as texting, blogging, email, chat rooms, and other online social networking sites, the opportunities for students to potentially tease and torment each other is seemingly uncontrollable. 
 
While the school's legal accountability is still in question, the Boston News reports that several bullying experts believe that the school’s leadership should have shown greater regard for Phoebe’s safety and wellbeing given the multiple reports of threats and harassments. Further supporting this stance, Elizabeth Englander, director of the Massachusetts Aggression Reduction Center, argues that schools must implement standardized procedures to foster communication among staff members and parents. A better system of communication can prevent students from falling through the cracks in a flawed system. 
 
Education specialists also criticize the school's weak response efforts, stating that the “school’s poor response is not unusual and highlights the need for mandated reporting laws and training on bullying prevention,” as reported by the Boston News. 
 
While Phoebe Prince's former South Hadley High School is being criticized for its lack of bullying policies and consequences, many public school leaders also are reacting to this recent event by reevaluating their own practices. 
 
Whether or not South Hadley High School’s current efforts to review and revise their bullying standards will be effective, in the meantime, the public anxiously awaits the legal ramifications of the responsibility the school's leaders may hold in the death of Phoebe Prince.

Additional Resources [+]
comments powered by Disqus
Public Schools and Bullying: The Issues and the Solutions
Public Schools and Bullying: The Issues and the Solutions
10 Ways to Protect Your Kids from Bullying at School
10 Ways to Protect Your Kids from Bullying at School
Recent Articles
April 22, 2017
Police departments on public school campuses have played a major role in reducing violent crime and the speed limit. Unfortunately, they are also fighting an uphill battle against budget cuts.
April 22, 2017
Which states have the most diverse public schools? We analyze our data to find how much diversity truly exists on public school campuses. Learn about the varying levels of school diversity in regions around the nation, as well as the benefits derived from ethnic diversity in schools.
April 21, 2017
Children are reading less and less in this country, and the effects of that are showing in their performance in school. However, there are a variety of ways parents can encourage their children to read – and hopefully to love reading!
Parenting and Learning Issues

Bullying

An overview of bullying in schools, laws to protect students, and the impact on education. This section provides great tips on protecting your child from being bullied or becoming a bully. Learn about the latest anti-bullying laws and see how cyber-bullying effects your child’s school performance.