Charter School Case Studies: Failures Despite Generous Funding and Stanford Backing

Updated |
Charter School Case Studies: Failures Despite Generous Funding and Stanford Backing
While there are many success stories of charter schools, there are also failures. Learn about two examples of charter schools that have not turned the tide in suffering school districts.
Charter schools have traditionally been known for producing high test scores and academically prepared students, despite facing challenges in districts that standard public schools have been unable to overcome. However, the establishment of a charter school does not guarantee improved performance all of the time. Even when plenty of money is invested and renowned academic experts are called in, the schools may fall short from time to time.
This video explains why charter schools can succeed.
This article reports on two charter schools that are struggling despite an infrastructure of support.
Trouble Brewing in New Jersey Charter School
Newark's Lady Liberty Academy was a troubled school that many in public education in New Jersey hoped to revive. Situated in a low-income area of the state, those involved with the charter school adopted a new commitment a year ago to show just what the right type of education could do for at-risk kids.
Newark Mayor Cory Booker wooed in public school superstar Glen Pinder, a high-profile principal from New York's Harlem Children's Zone. Pinder was given the challenging task of turning over a new leaf at Lady Liberty, raising test scores and morale of staff and students at the same time.
Unfortunately, even the best-laid plan run amuck at times, and Lady Liberty was apparently not immune to its share of conflict, according to recent reports at With Pinder came an entirely new administrative team, straight from his home field of New York. The group fell to their new project with gusto, fixing up the school building from the inside out, ordering all new curriculum and searching for test preparation innovations.
Although parents saw the changes when the school opened their doors last fall, the honeymoon was short-lived. Pinder announced to parents that the school was failing, and that they needed to make serious improvements before state officials visited the school that December. However, hold-over staffers became concerned that the administration was going too far in staging the visit by state officials, prepping parents and students for interviews to make the best impression possible.
This video documents the construction of Lady Liberty Academy.
By January, internal conflict had peaked within Lady Liberty Academy, with the proposed firing of a kindergarten teacher and angry words and feelings on both sides of the aisle. Closed-door meetings that followed only served to fuel the fire, resulting in the resignation of school board members until only two seats on the nine-member board remained filled. Fires continued to smolder within the school's staff and administration throughout the year, and when it finally came to a close, the test scores of the students showed that academics had suffered as a result.
This year opens a new chapter at Lady Liberty Academy, with high hopes that the school will finally begin to show improvement and meet the expectations that were so high just one short year ago. Pinder, who is still the principal at the school, said that "it takes time to turn the ocean liner around." Hopefully, the ship will find smoother waters during this academic year.
California Charter School Facing Possible Closure
Stanford New School is another charter school that began with high hopes of transforming low-income students into academic superstars. According to a report in the New York Times, the school had all the ingredients for success: the ability to spend an additional $3,000 per student each year and the experience and support of some of the nation's finest educators at Stanford University.

The school opened in East Palo Alto, an area with a large minority and immigrant population, as well as a long history of poverty and crime, according to the Huffington Post. Still, the right ingredients should mean a better academic experience for students, right?
Unfortunately, that has yet to be the case at Stanford New School. The institution is still on the list of the persistently lowest-achieving schools in California and faced closure at the end of the previous school year. Deborah Stipek, dean of the Stanford School of Education told the NYT, "We are all in shock." Dr. Stipek added that starting a new school "takes time." However, she also admitted, "It's a risky business. We rolled up our sleeves and opened a school in a financially and socially-challenged environment so that we could prepare teachers and leaders for the real challenges they will face."
This video offers a tour of East Palo Alto Academy.
Unfortunately, all the hard work and money do not appear to be enough to keep Stanford New School's hopes and dreams alive.
Charter schools are often opened in challenging areas to offer students an alternative to a failing public school system. While there are indeed many success stories, unfortunately, some of these efforts prove that money and experience are sometimes not sufficient for bringing about the type of changes needed to transform the face of public education today.
Questions? Contact us on Facebook. @publicschoolreview

Additional Resources [+]
comments powered by Disqus
Why Single-Sex Public Schools are Growing in Popularity
Why Single-Sex Public Schools are Growing in Popularity
Local Schools and Charter Schools: Can They be Close Allies?
Local Schools and Charter Schools: Can They be Close Allies?
Recent Articles
Jay McDowell, a public school teacher in Howell, evicted a student for making anti-homosexual comments, but now the instructor faces suspension. Learn about the national controversy that involves this local Michigan teacher.
A six-year old in Aurora, Colorado, was suspended after singing an LMFAO song to a little girl in his class and reportedly “shaking his booty.” We look at the case and the sexual harassment problem in public schools today.
After playing rapper Macklemore's "Same Love" pro-gay rights rap song in class, a Michigan teacher was suspended with no pay. We explore the controversy.
About Public Schools

Types of Public Schools

Explore the different types of public schools, from charter to language immersion, and learn about the unique pros and cons of each type. Is a co-ed or single sex classroom best for your child? Charter school or magnet? Read expert advice and get valuable tips on the various public education programs available and how to choose what works best for your family.